Getting an unexpected question in an academic interview can disrupt your train of thought, leaving you unsure of how to respond or how to link it back to your strengths. Many interviewers use this tactic intentionally to see how well you adapt, think critically, and communicate under pressure. While this type of question can be challenging, it’s also an opportunity to demonstrate your ability to navigate complex topics and present yourself confidently.
When confronted with an unexpected question, the first step is to avoid reacting too quickly. A brief pause can help you stay calm and compose your thoughts. This momentary silence shows the interviewer that you are considering the question carefully, rather than scrambling for an answer. In that short pause, focus on reframing the question or finding a way to bridge the conversation back to a topic that showcases your expertise.
Are you preparing for an Academic Interview? OmniInterview provides personalized coaching programs to non-native English speakers preparing for Academic Interviews.
If you are expecting an interview in the future, consider becoming our next successful client. Let's find a time when we can speak about your interview and how OmniInterview can help you prepare for a confident interview in a Discovery Session.
Reframe the question
Reframing is a powerful technique that involves interpreting the question from a different perspective.
Instead of thinking about the question’s literal meaning, consider the broader theme behind it and how it might relate to your field.
For example, if asked about a topic outside your research area, you can reframe by highlighting a related skill or experience that aligns with your background. This approach not only answers the question but also shifts the focus back to your strengths. Reframing is useful when you feel the question is too broad, confusing, or even designed to test your response in an unfamiliar context. Shifting the perspective helps you stay in control of your narrative without appearing evasive.
Bridge the question
Another effective strategy is the bridging technique. Bridging is used when the question asked feels disconnected from your expertise, or when you want to redirect the conversation to a core strength. This approach involves acknowledging the question, briefly addressing it, and then naturally steering the conversation back to a key point you want to emphasize.
For instance, if asked a question like, “What are your thoughts on current economic policies?”—a topic that may not be directly related to your research—you can say,
“While I haven’t focused specifically on economic policies, my research on international collaboration has shown me how interconnected policies and academic work can be.”
By bridging the conversation, you demonstrate flexibility and an ability to connect diverse ideas back to your strengths.
Once you’ve applied either reframing or bridging, use the (I)STAR(T) structure to build a clear, concise answer. The (I)STAR(T) method is an approach that helps organize your thoughts systematically, allowing you to deliver a structured response that highlights your strengths and takeaways. Start with a brief Introduction that provides context for your answer. Describe the Situation with only the necessary background information. Move quickly into the Task, where you outline the goal or challenge you faced. The Actions section is the most critical; include 3-5 key actions you took to address the challenge, ensuring each action clearly demonstrates your skills and problem-solving abilities. After explaining the actions, state the Result and then conclude with the Takeaway, which should summarize what you learned and how it relates to the interviewer’s question.
For example, if you receive an off-topic question like, “How would you handle a conflict between two team members?” and your expertise is more focused on independent research, you can respond using (I)STAR(T).
Begin by acknowledging the relevance of conflict resolution skills in research settings. Then, share a situation where you navigated a disagreement during a collaborative project. Focus on specific actions, such as how you facilitated communication, created a plan for assigning roles, and followed up with team members to ensure clarity. Emphasize the positive outcome and end with a key learning about how these skills would be valuable in a future academic setting. This structure ensures that your response is clear, coherent, and reflective of your professional abilities.
Handling unexpected questions is not just about staying calm; it’s about demonstrating that you can think critically, adapt under pressure, and communicate your strengths even when the topic is unfamiliar. Practicing these techniques beforehand can make a significant difference in your ability to handle curveballs during an academic interview. Working with a coach can provide you with a space to practice and receive targeted feedback, making it easier to master these strategies.
Master the conversation
If you’re preparing for an upcoming academic interview and want to feel more confident handling unexpected questions, consider booking a discovery session with OmniInterview. In our coaching sessions, we focus on helping you develop personalized strategies that turn challenging questions into opportunities to highlight your strengths. Whether you’re preparing for a graduate admissions interview, an academic scholarship interview, or any other high-stakes academic conversation, we can help you approach it with clarity and confidence.
Ready to start? Book your discovery session.
Comments